The Eagles finished the meet with 50 points, just three behind the winning Washington and Lee team.
Mills dominated the meet with a winning time of 23:20.50 on the 6K course at the Claytor Nature Study Center. Smith finished comfortably in second with a time of 23:53.40, 16 seconds ahead of the third-place finisher.
BC senior Katie Notarangelo cracked the Top 10 with a time of 25:22.10 to place 10th. Stephanie Breen and Whitney Fitzgerald rounded out the Eagles scoring as both finished inside the Top 20. Breen was 17th with a time of 26:57.50, one spot ahead of Fitzgerald who crossed the line with a time of 27:01.60.